Amish Sugar Cookies

(19)

printable version


Comments 353 comments   

This cookie is a very soft sugar cookie that is made with a batter rather than a dough, but is really good.

Prep Time: 15 Min
Cook Time: 10 Min
Ready In: 25 Min

Ingredients:

1 1/2 cups vegetable oil
1 1/2 cups white sugar
2 eggs
4 cups all-purpose flour
1 teaspoon baking soda
1 teaspoon baking powder
1 cup buttermilk
3/4 teaspoon salt
3/4 teaspoon vanilla extract


Directions:

1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F (175 degrees C).

2. Mix together vegetable oil (yes, 1 1/2 cups of vegetable oil), sugar and eggs. Mix in the flour, baking soda, baking powder, buttermilk, salt and vanilla.

3. Pour teaspoon-sized amounts of batter onto cookie sheets, leaving plenty of room in between. These cookies will puff up and get large.

4. Bake for 8 to 10 minutes.


Nutritional Information
Amount Per Serving Calories: 85 | Total Fat: 4.8g | Cholesterol: 6mg


Source: AllRecipes

 

by WRKGIBBONS   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SUGARMOOKIE   
tasty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MUUMMY   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LORAC3265   
Ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ANA.BANANA   
need to try these!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TIGEROFTHEKNIGHT   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TJG124   
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ANGUSCD   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CLDAMON   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SHELBYACAT   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MARY_7   
good recipe
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SAMANTHAWHO2   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SPICELIVES   
Thank you
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JDCRACKERBOX   
ok
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ARTBUECKER   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PEYOTECOYOTE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SHANWIN   
Thanks.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CND579   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SCRAPPYDOO069   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by WENDY500   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PERMASMILE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CLARINETDAWG   
Thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by 190663   
Thanks!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TINAMYERS   
now these are really good. ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by AZACOB   
Ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ABBY20   
Yum
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TJG124   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MEGANKC   
thanks!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MEGANKC   
Thanks!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by FLYNDRGN   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BLACKCAT13   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GLJJMB   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by EGGSHELL28   
thank you
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PLG24   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CHESTERBOY   
Thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by RAINBOWRIBBON   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SOBERLIZZARD   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by EGGOFHEN   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BOBLAT9   
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ADP0831   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by WASJUSTKILLED   
Thanks!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BOOBEAT1984   
Ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ILLINI02   
Thank you!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BOOKWORMER3   
Thanks for sharing
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BKDECKER   
Sounds Amazing, can't wait to give this a try.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by RJLBUD   
ok
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CARLEY_T   
yum
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CATHYLB56560   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CIUFO   
ok
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SUSANLAYNE   
sugar cakes
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by 9637   
Thank you
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by 555513   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by STRAW-B   
yum!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BJE123   
thank you
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LALA100   
yum
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TMEDARIS   
Thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PUPPYDUPPY   
yum!!!!!!!!!!!!!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MEMAW1   
yum
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by KARENZODA   
yummy
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JILLW45   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JILLW45   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by B.J. IN ILLINOIS   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LSCHRADE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BLIZZARINO   
mmmmm
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by EGGOFHEN   
yum
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by QUILTINGJ   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PATTY1218   
thx
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DRLAHRU   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by YOMOMDAD   
Yum
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by KIMMIEG.   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by STRONI   
wow
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by FIRSTCAT   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MIZZOULADY   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ELIZABETHASQUINI   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by REDCATWOMAN   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BRIE2   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LINDAKR   
A new twist on sugar cookies~
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CARLENECOLLINS   
yum
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DRAGONFAIRY2   
yummy
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SMAJPP   
Big old-fashioned sugar cookies--YUM. Pure comfort food.
by RJKELSO1480   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TLCROCKETT   
Thanks--sound good.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LITAS   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ONCODOC   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LINDABRAND   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by NURSEROSEMARIE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by KDDONOVAN   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DLINGBLOOM   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LOUISE   
TY
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MRSNHBSA   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BOB455   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SALVADORARIAS   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by 1000009949701   
pass
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by 92651   
sounds good
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MKHULSE   
yum yum
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by AMBERANNIE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SPAGADOR   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BLACKCAT13   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by AMY1   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by AGGIEDOO   
yummy
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GRAM1048   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ZIGGY7   
Thanks!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by RLONG1150   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by NUTTIER1   
thanksthanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CHRISUSA46   
my grandma made these cookies 60 years ago! thanks for the reminder.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CHRISUSA46   
my grandma made these cookies 60 years ago! thanks for the reminder.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SHASHA192000   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by EGGSHELL28   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JOANP   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CKCOX   
ok
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ANONYMOUS TOO :-)(-:   
Thank you
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LAURE2   
yummy
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MUGHIBEAR   
thank you
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JUANTORRES   
TY
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MAMACHELE51   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ONGMINGH   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by HINTON4PLUS1   
sounds good ty!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by EMPRESSPIE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by KALLCHER   
Thank you.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ANGELLESLIE101   
Will try these!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by FLOMARY   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CPOINDEXTER   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CORNPIGS   
ok
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by Y1DER   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GRAVITTR   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by KATLYN00   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by OLYMPIAR   
sounds good to me - thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by OPIEDY   
yum
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BEACHREADER   
Thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CODYB   
Thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DONNASWA   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TAMMY_534   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SHARONPEVA   
yum plain and simple
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SANDY413   
sounds very good
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LURKER#1   
Thank you, must try
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CHIREX99   
m
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ABRILLUV   
k
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by COMPMAMA   
Thanks for sharing.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JOY11   
try
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BLOSSER   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ZOONOSIS   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MYAPAIN   
printed
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SPONIN   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by REIGN10   
Thanx
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MEL98942   
ok
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by NDAKOTA BLUE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by KYCAMP   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PMB743   
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DEBSCOUSIN   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DIVI TREE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by FATLIL   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BROUJP   
Thank-You.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SHELLEYBERBACH   
yum
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by RICHARDTELLIOTTSR   
easy and good!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CLAUDIA229   
Thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by REBAB   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by NLAWYER   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TLOFFHAUS   
looks so yummy...thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BARB9457   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CPOGIE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by NEWME36   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by HOMY20   
LOOKS AND SOUNDS GOOD.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LEWISTON   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MELANIE K   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JDIPAOLA   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JMH5679   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GORILLAGIRL   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JERRYHIGG   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JERRYHIGG   
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MYAMY0502   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BWHITED   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by FRRONALD   
Simple and good.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by 4908   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LINDAANGEL   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by KAYSTAR   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MICRONUTS   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BLA1228   
Looks can be deceiving---good old Amish recipes are wonderful!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MANNYBA   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DRLAHRU   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JUSTBECKY0512   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BAIKU   
k
by COOPZ   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TOPSEABUG   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JKOMJIAN   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by WALLYFAN1   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by RJLBUD   
nice
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by HAH13   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by EEEK   
different
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by YOSHIE95   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BPHMOM   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by AFD302   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CHABIAS   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PEIO   
I think I'm going to like this! Thanks! :)
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PLG24   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PLG24   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ARKE3   
Thanks.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by NWCWC   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by VACTOR2   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SASSYSUEFL   
yummy..ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LABESAJA   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PRUI   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BABAWAWA   
Sounds delicious!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SUE1933   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GIRLE04   
This sounds really neat
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JMA2005   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CHRISTMAS2   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MASTFAN   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TIGGERGER2000   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DIANA1006   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MIKEINTEXAS   
Thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CHELLEMS   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by KATHY1007   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GMBUSDRIVER46   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TERRIOBRIEN   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by FPAJVAB   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TEALSKIES   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LISAJOS   
nothing can beat an old Amish recipe, especially sugar cookies!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BARINSKY   
So true, so true!
by BIESTEK   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MIKEJO   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by WEENIEWIFE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TERRI14   
a keeper
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by NANCYYC   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JBREPAIR   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by STELLATJ   
thanks for the recipe
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by KKWEDDLE   
Thanks!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by FIREDUST37   
Thank you.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PEACHIE2   
Thanks!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SAHOBSON   
great
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by FRANNY-LU   
Yummy,ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SLLUBS   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by 2767   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SKYMAN103   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by HEMEN2   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SAJIT25   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by HBBULL   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LISALJOST   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by A HYGIENIST   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ICANWATCH   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SASSYK   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JUNAMOON   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MOTOBABE   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PUTER_TATER   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by 080559   
yum
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by AMAEBI   
Thanks.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PUMPKINSMILE2008   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GRANPAELMER   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MSMAGGIE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MSMAGGIE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MARRISA0733   
nice
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by N7NICKYS7N   
love these
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LDCOX   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by KRIZZEL   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by VDAURIA   
Yumm thanks for sharing, I'll make these with a nice glaze on top
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by 8182122   
Or drizzled with chocolate, yummy!
by NOMOMOMO   
sounds good. TY
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BRIM   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DFAN   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SJEASLER   
Thanks for sharing.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GINNYMKITTY   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PEPSIGRANDMA   
Ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CATIES   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MOGAE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ONFIRE4HIM316   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MONIKATUL   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by OAFMAN69   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SWEETIEWHEATIESCOTIE   
Thanks for sharing. Love buttermilk in things but just can't drink it.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DIMSUM12   
aaaaa
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PMKIRKWOOD @MAC.COM   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MSLILY64   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GLKA   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by YJB1970   
Thank You
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DANCINGTIGGER5   
Thank you!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CATERNIA   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MARYFERN   
Sounds good.....looks not so much!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CLARKDL   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by WINONA2   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ROSEGULDEN   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LAKSHMISAJ   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by FUN4CLC   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GIRLS2   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by VARNELL35   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SJFISHER   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by WAUNELL   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by TUMBLETHORN   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SHVESTER3   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by 2JENNY   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by NWMOM   
ok
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by REVVER   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ZOLYSHKA1   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PRINCESSPOWELL   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by 8FOR3   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SHELTIESHA   
TY
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by RZUROVEC   
Thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JACKI2954   
Thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ABUDOG   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GHAYNIE   
yum
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PSEUDO1616   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PAMTIM   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DYIMOVOSHKA   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PRELUDER93   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by RGG52   
Thanks.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SAVANNAHA   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SHOP2CHIC   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by COWCHIPPER   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SANDY314   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MOM294   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CUBAN1988   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GRAYSON   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CITYDINER   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MB2003   
Thank you!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DMG260   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CHESTERBOY   
Thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JSCHNACK   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CHILPEP   
Thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LHUTCH64   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by WEDGEL   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by LRDORN   
I have seen this recipe a very long time ago. Not going to lose this one again! Thanks.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BETHERS   
interesting
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ZOLYSHKA   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by REFUNDER50   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by HOMELL   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GAILFREE   
thx
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by AJBANAS   
thanks so much
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CB6658   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ABZO3   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by NORRIS   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by KSWALSH   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by RAD1259   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by PAULETTE294   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ALS6437   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by GABBYMH   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ASWP   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by MYMEEMER   
Thanks for sharing.
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CAROLAB   
Yum! These sound good! Thank you!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by DADISH   
Thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SHELBYACAT   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CHITCHATCHANDLER   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CARROTTHEAD   
have to try this. thank you
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by CLEANONE   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by JOERACER   
These do not look appealing.. thought Amish were better cooks than this??????????????????
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by NAPOLEONBAKER   
ditto
by TAMMYANGEL   
thanks
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SKY40   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by NLLIB   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by SHINAR00   
I love Amish anything!
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by BANMID   
So do I!
by PURPLE1010   
me too! .. and the Amish Market is open today! :)
by SEAYA712   
Yummm...TY
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by HEDGECLIP   
very good
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by 20456   
agree
by RAVHPB   
ty
reply   Report abuse report abuse
by ADDMUP   
yty
reply   Report abuse report abuse

 

Go back to the Main Page of the Archives.

Do you have a Helpful Hint of your own?
Tell us about it and we might publish it.

Do you have problem? Maybe we can help.
Click Here to tell us about it.